All of Jenna St. James’s paranormal cozy mysteries and romances share one magical world. It centers on the Paranormal Apprehension and Detention Agency (PADA), the supernatural law enforcement agency that keeps witches, shifters, fae, vampires and every other magical being in line. Characters cross over between series, so here’s the best order to read them in. You don’t have to follow it, since each series stands on its own, but the A Witch in the Woods series is where it all began.

Optional prequel: Enchanted Island Mysteries: Serena & Grant (three novellas). Free when you sign up for Jenna’s newsletter at jennastjames.com.

1. A Witch in the Woods (Paranormal Cozy Mystery)

A midlife witch starts over as a game warden on Enchanted Island, with a talking, flying porcupine named Needles and a gargoyle sheriff.

  1. Deadly Claws
  2. Deadly Coins
  3. Deadly Critic
  4. Deadly Cocktail
  5. Deadly Coffin
  6. Deadly Caramel
  7. Deadly Client
  8. Deadly Coven
  9. Deadly Corsage
  10. Deadly Cries
  11. Deadly Doctor
  12. Deadly Vines
  13. Deadly Goodbye
  14. Deadly Feud
  15. Deadly Focus
  16. Deadly Vows
  17. Deadly Waters
  18. Deadly Souls
  19. Deadly Secrets
  20. Deadly Yule
  21. Deadly Mixer
  22. Deadly Storm
  23. Deadly Arrow
  24. Deadly Seeds
  25. Deadly Rains
  26. Deadly Tempo
  27. Deadly Summer
  28. Deadly Circus
  29. Deadly Flame
  30. Deadly Mansion
  31. Deadly Past
  32. Deadly Deeds
  33. Deadly Cheer
  34. Deadly Hour
  35. Deadly Calling
  36. Deadly Surprise
  37. Deadly Enemy
  38. Deadly Rose
  39. Deadly Diversion

2. A Kara Hilder Mystery (Paranormal Cozy Mystery)

A spinoff of A Witch in the Woods. Kara Hilder, a Valkyrie witch, teams up with Zane, a Fallen Angel, to solve crimes in the supernatural town of Mystic Cove and to go undercover for PADA. With Savage the snarky cat and Link the pixie.

  1. Sounds of Murder
  2. Tee Up to Die
  3. Heartless Homicide
  4. Watery Grave
  5. Ice-Cold Killer
  6. An Unlucky Murder
  7. Murder at Mystic Market
  8. Murder on Winter Island
  9. Assisted Murder
  10. Meditation & Murder
  11. The Ogre’s Last Lesson
  12. A Soul to Harvest
  13. Tastes Like Murder
  14. Signed, Sealed, Deceased
  15. Yule Spells & Wedding Bells
  16. A New Year Nightmare
  17. Wish of Death
  18. The Last Valentine
  19. Bridal Bash & Betrayal
  20. Fitted for Death
  21. Death of the Green Fairy

3. Enchanted Waters Mysteries (Paranormal Cozy Mystery, co-written with Stephanie Damore)

A mermaid-witch detective teams up with a treasure-hunting demigod and Glo, a snarky glow-in-the-dark dragon, in the Bermuda Triangle.

  1. Tangled Waters
  2. Haunted Waters
  3. Cursed Waters
  4. Festive Waters
  5. Toxic Waters
  6. Closing Waters
  7. Cold Waters
  8. Lucky Waters
  9. Troubled Waters
  10. Wilting Waters
  11. Lost Waters
  12. Moving Waters
  13. Sparkling Waters
  14. Mystery Waters
  15. Pairing Waters
  16. Scared Waters

4. A Moonlight Bay Paranormal Cozy Romance

Sweet, funny paranormal cozy romance set in the magical seaside town of Moonlight Bay.

  1. A Dash of Wolf
  2. Treasure in the Storm
  3. Shots with the Star

Box Sets

Where Should I Start?

Start with Deadly Claws, Book 1 of A Witch in the Woods. Or, if you’d rather begin with a Valkyrie and a Fallen Angel, start with Sounds of Murder.